The Clearly filtered water pitcher, Epic pure pitcher, ProOne water pitcher, and ReShape pitcher are the 4 most effective water filter pitchers that removes fluoride.
Water pitchers aren’t the only way to remove fluoride. You can also opt for other fluoride removal methods such as fluoride water filters with reverse osmosis and gravity technology, but water pitchers are one of the cheapest options available.
Fluoride Water Pitcher Comparison Table
- Filtration technology: Affinity Filtration Technology with a unique structure and contaminant magnet
- Fluoride reduction rate: A minimum of 99.5%
- Number of removed contaminants: 365+
- Water Capacity: 10 cups (80oz)
- Filter Capacity: 100 gallons (4 months)
- NSF certifications: NSF standards 42, 53, 244, 401, and P473
- Warranty: Lifetime
- Filtration technology: A proprietary blend of different filtration technologies including adsorption
- Fluoride reduction rate: A minimum of 97.8%
- Number of removed contaminants: 200+
- Water Capacity: 8 cups (68oz)
- Filter Capacity: 150 gallons (4 to 5 months)
- NSF certifications: NSF/ANSI Standards 42, 53, 401, & P473
- Warranty: Lifetime
- Filtration technology: Silver-infused filter with granular carbon core
- Fluoride reduction rate: A minimum of 97.5%
- Number of removed contaminants: 200+
- Water Capacity: 6-7 cups (54oz)
- Filter Capacity: 225 gallons (6 months)
- NSF certifications: NSF/ANSI Standards 42, 53, P231, P401, and P473
- Warranty: 120 days
- Filtration technology: Catalytic carbon with an alkalinity raiser
- Fluoride reduction rate: N/A
- Number of removed contaminants: Unspecified
- Water Capacity: 10 cups (80 oz)
- Filter Capacity: 79 gallons (1 to 2 months)
- NSF certifications: Unspecified
- Warranty: 1 year
Best Water Filter Pitchers To Remove Fluoride:
- Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher – The Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher offers a minimum of 99.5% fluoride reduction rate and 365 contaminants reduced in total. | (Jump to Review)
- Epic Pure Water Filter Pitcher – Made of 100% recyclable and replaceable materials and with a fluoride removal rate of 97.4%, the Epic Pure Water Filter Pitcher is the best eco-friendly pitcher in its category. | (Jump to Review)
- ProOne Water Filter Pitcher – The ProOne Water Filter Pitcher offers 97.5% fluoride reduction, 200+ contaminant removal and 225 gallons of water filter capacity which lasts approximately 6 months. | (Jump to Review)
- Reshape Water 10-Cup Pitcher – The Reshape Water Pitcher is a good pick if you’re on a budget, although we couldn’t ascertain the exact fluoride reduction rate. | (Jump to Review)
1. Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher for Fluoride
- Filtration technology: Affinity Filtration Technology with a unique structure and contaminant magnet
- Fluoride reduction rate: A minimum of 99.5%
- Number of removed contaminants: 365+
- Water Capacity: 10 cups (80oz)
- Filter Capacity: 100 gallons (4 months)
- NSF certifications: NSF standards 42, 53, 401, and P473
- Warranty: Lifetime
- Impressive fluoride reduction rate with 99.5% thanks to its unique filtration technology
- 365+ other contaminants removed
- Has all the relevant NSF certifications
- Lifetime warranty
- One of the most expensive water pitchers on the market
- You need to replace its filters once every four months
The Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher is a superior product not only in the category of water pitchers but compared to other home water treatment units in general.
The staggering number of 365 contaminants reduced (see the NSF-certified performance data sheet for the full list), the uncontested fluoride reduction rate of 99.5%, and its lifetime warranty easily make it the best water pitcher for fluoride removal.
So, how does Clearly Filtered achieve such impressive numbers when it comes to fluoride reduction? While most other water filters depend on variations of activated carbon filtration for this particular purpose, the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher utilizes a patented technology called Affinity Filtration, which brings together different filtration methods:
- Mesh filter: To increase the efficiency of the filters that follow after, a woven mesh screen blocks large particles like sediment, little pieces of rock, clay, sand, and dust
- Granulated coconut carbon: Water filter manufacturers often employ standard activated carbon to remove taste, odor, and color and reduce some chemicals like chlorine. Granulated carbon is an upgrade on standard carbon, and it can reduce many other contaminants like PFAS, making the job of the main filter that takes over next easier. However, keep in mind that this filtration technology doesn’t play a role in fluoride removal.
- Composite shell: There are two main features of the composite shell of the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher: its structure is full of twists and turns, and it works as a contaminant magnet. These twists and turns increase the contact time between water and filter, making it more effective. On the other hand, the contaminant magnet draws and traps impurities with an ionic structure, like fluoride and lead.
Of course, the superb performance of the filter in removing fluoride and 364 other contaminants is reflected in the unit’s price ($81). The Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher is the most expensive item on our list, especially when you take into account that you need to replace its filters once every four months (since they have a 100-gallon capacity).
2. Epic Pure Water Filter Pitcher
- Filtration technology: A proprietary blend of different filtration technologies including adsorption
- Fluoride reduction rate: A minimum of 97.8%
- Number of removed contaminants: 200+
- Water Capacity: 8 cups (68oz)
- Filter Capacity: 150 gallons (4 to 5 months)
- NSF certifications: NSF/ANSI Standards 42, 53, 401, & P473
- Warranty: Lifetime
- 97.8% fluoride reduction rate is quite decent
- The most eco-friendly item on our list that’s made of 100% recyclable material
- The manufacturer is a member of the 1% for the Planet
- 150-gallon filtration capacity is pretty great
- Lifetime warranty
- 8 cups water capacity may not be sufficient to provide for large families
- The Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher has a better fluoride reduction rate with 99.5%
The Epic Pure Water Pitcher can reduce 97.8% of fluoride from your drinking water and is tested and certified to remove 200 other contaminants. Although these numbers are humble compared to what the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher can do, its filtration capacity of 150 gallons and the fact that it’s made of totally reusable, replaceable, and recyclable materials make it a worthy runner-up.
Like the Clearly Filtered, the technology behind the Epic Pure Water Filter Pitcher is a unique blend of different techniques like adsorption, absorption, chelating, and in-depth filtration.
However, only the adsorption method is effective against fluoride ions in water. As fluoride consists of negatively charged ions (anions), only the adsorptive media in the main filter of the Epic Pure in covalent bonds can trap this mineral compound.
In addition, the Epic Filter has a higher filtration capacity than the Clearly Filtered. While the latter can only endure 100 gallons of contaminated water, the former can serve you 150 gallons of pure water, which equals four to five months, depending on usage. Considering that you’ll need to buy replacement filters, this particular feature makes Epic Pure the more economical choice.
What we like about this fluoride filter is that it’s completely recyclable. The manufacturer even runs its own recycling program, in which you get a free filter for every four old filters you send for recycling, which further contributes to its affordability.
Of course, that’s not the only way Epic Pure is eco-friendly. The product’s packaging is made of 100% compostable material, and the brand is a member of the 1% for the Planet.
As in the case of Clearly Filtered, Epic Pure has a lifetime warranty, which is a great testament to how much trust the manufacturer has in its pitchers.
However, we should note that the water capacity of this pitcher is only 68, roughly equaling 8 cups. Although it’s a good number for small families, large families need more.
3. ProOne Water Filter Pitcher for Fluoride
- Filtration technology: Silver-infused filter with granular carbon core
- Fluoride reduction rate: A minimum of 97.5%
- Number of removed contaminants: 200+
- Water Capacity: 6-7 cups (54oz)
- Filter Capacity: 225 gallons (6 months)
- NSF certifications: NSF/ANSI Standards 42, 53, P231, P401, and P473
- Warranty: 120 days
- 97.5% fluoride reduction rate is quite decent
- Unique filter placement prevents cross-contamination
- 225-gallon filter capacity presents the most durable option on the market
- 120-day warranty is inferior to the warranty options of other products on our list
- 54oz water capacity is humble
The tested and certified performance data sheet of the ProOne Water Filter Pitcher shows that it’s able to reduce fluoride levels in drinking water by 97.5%. We know this number is lower than the two products we reviewed earlier, but the 225-gallon life expectancy of its filter secures it a place on our list.
Like all other innovative water pitchers that can remove fluoride, the ProOne entertains a blend of different filtration technologies, including silver-infused ionic exchange properties and a carbon-based granular media at its core. Thanks to these, it can efficiently reduce fluoride levels.
One feature of the ProOne Water Pitcher is its unique filter placement. While in most water pitchers, like the Epic Pure above, the filter itself remains in touch with filtered water, the vertical design of the ProOne makes it impossible for the filtered water to come into contact with the filter. Thus, it eliminates the possibility of leakage of contaminants like fluoride from the filter into the water, which is of great importance when the filter nears the end of its life expectancy.
Apart from its capability to remove fluoride, its life expectancy is the second most important factor that convinced us the ProOne deserved a place on our list. With a filtration capacity of 225 gallons, which means roughly six months, this water pitcher has the most durable filter on our list and on the market in general.
That being said, the ProOne Water Pitcher is the worst item on our list in one particular aspect: warranty. Whereas both the Clearly Filtered and the Epic Pure pitchers have a lifetime warranty, the ProOne is covered for only 120 days, which leaves a lot to be desired.
Furthermore, it only has a 54 oz filtered water capacity, roughly equal to six to seven cups of water, making it unsuitable for large families or households with higher drinking water needs.
4. Reshape Water 10-Cup Pitcher
- Filtration technology: Catalytic carbon with an alkalinity raiser
- Fluoride reduction rate: Unspecified
- Number of removed contaminants: Unspecified
- Water Capacity: 10 cups (80 oz)
- Filter Capacity: 79 gallons (1 to 2 months)
- NSF certifications: Unspecified
- Warranty: 1 year
- One of the most affordable water pitchers that can remove fluoride on the market
- It raises the alkalinity of the water so you can reap the health benefits of alkaline water
- It features state-of-the-art catalytic carbon technology
- The 79-gallon capacity of its filter is easily the humblest on our list
- It doesn’t have a performance data sheet that gives us an idea about how much fluoride it reduces and what other contaminants it removes
- Only one-year of warranty isn’t great
If you don’t want to pay too much for a water filter pitcher that removes fluoride, then you can do no better than Reshape Water’s 10-Cup Pitcher, as it only costs $29.50. Despite its affordability, it can also remove many contaminants, including fluoride, chlorine, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs).
Unlike the unique filtration technology blends of all the three water pitchers we analyzed so far, the Reshape Water only uses catalytic carbon technology to remove fluoride. Unlike activated carbon blocks that can only remove aesthetic impurities like taste, odor, and color, catalytic carbon is electrically charged to target the ionic structures of VOCs, lead, and fluoride.
An added bonus of the Reshape Pitcher is that it adds healthy minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium to the water, raising its alkalinity. Alkaline water has a handful of health benefits, including maintaining the pH of our blood, preventing acid reflux, and protecting from oxidative damage.
The manufacturer also boasts that its filters are 25% to 33% more affordable than the filters of other water pitchers on the market. However, that doesn’t necessarily make them preferable, especially in the long term. As the filtration capacity of these filters is only 79 gallons, requiring replacement in one to two months, they may even end up being less economical than the replacement filters of the ProOne Water Pitcher.
Furthermore, unlike the other options on our list, the manufacturer of the Reshape doesn’t provide a performance data sheet for this particular filter.
In other words, we don’t know what its fluoride removal rate is, what other contaminants it can remove, and with how much success.
Lastly, although its one-year warranty is better than what ProOne offers, it still pales in comparison to the warranty options of our top two products: Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher and Epic Pure Water Pitcher.
How We Evaluated Fluoride Water Pitchers
We based our initial research and subsequent list on:
- Fluoride reduction rate
- Contaminants removed (in number)
- Water capacity
- Filter capacity
- NSF certifications
- Warranty
- Price
Now, let’s see what these criteria mean and how the water pitchers on our list fared against each other on all these fronts.
Fluoride Reduction Rate
Fluoride reduction rate indicates the minimum percentage of a filter’s capability to reduce fluoride.
Manufacturers provide these numbers in the performance data sheets of their products. The data sheets are prepared by the certified labs following independent tests on the effectiveness of a water treatment system.
The best item on our list in terms of its fluoride reduction rate is the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher, with 99.5%. The manufacturer of the Reshape Water Pitcher, on the other hand, doesn’t give any data on the efficiency of its product when it comes to fluoride removal/reduction.
| Water Filter Pitcher | Fluoride Reduction Rate |
|---|---|
| Clearly Filtered | 99.5% |
| Epic Pure | 97.8% |
| ProOne | 97.5% |
| Reshape | Not provided |
Contaminants Removed
Simply put, contaminants removed signifies how many contaminants a given water pitcher is tested and certified to remove. Similar to the fluoride reduction rate, manufacturers provide the list of contaminants their products can remove in performance data sheets prepared by independent labs.
In this aspect, too, the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher is the clear champion with its impressive number of more than 365 contaminants removed. Typically, the Reshape Water Pitcher doesn’t feature a performance data sheet so we have no way of knowing how many contaminants it removes or reduces.
| Water Filter Pitcher | Contaminants Removed |
|---|---|
| Clearly Filtered | 365+ |
| Epic Pure | 200+ |
| ProOne | 200+ |
| Reshape | Not provided |
Water Capacity
Water capacity is how much filtered water a water pitcher can provide in one fill. It’s often expressed in terms of oz or ‘cups.’
The Clearly Filtered and Reshape pitchers share the top spot. ProOne, on the other hand, comes last, with a capacity of 54 oz (6 to 7 cups).
| Water Filter Pitcher | Water Capacity |
|---|---|
| Clearly Filtered | 80oz (10 cups) |
| Epic Pure | 68oz (8 cups) |
| ProOne | 54oz (6 to 7 cups) |
| Reshape | 80oz (10 cups) |
Filtration Capacity (or Filter Life)
Filtration capacity is an indication of how many gallons of water a filter can treat before it loses its effectiveness. Once the filter treats as much water as indicated in its filter life specification, you’ll need to replace it.
The ProOne Water Filter Pitcher is the most economical option on our list, with its 225-gallon capacity. Despite its affordability, you’ll need to replace the filter of the Reshape Water Pitcher after every 79 gallons of filtered water, which makes it the worst choice when it comes to capacity.
| Water Filter Pitcher | Filtration Capacity |
|---|---|
| Clearly Filtered | 100 gallons |
| Epic Pure | 150 gallons |
| ProOne | 225 gallons |
| Reshape | 79 gallons |
NSF Certifications
The National Sanitation Foundation certifies water treatment products based on whether what they can remove and what they’re made of is in accordance with independent lab tests. In that sense, its certifications prove that these filters function as the manufacturers advertise.
The NSF certifications the products on our list have are:
- NSF Standard 42: The NSF 42 pertains to aesthetic impurities like chlorine, taste, odor, and color regulated under the National Secondary Drinking Water Regulations set by the Environmental Protection Agency.
- NSF Standard 53: The NSF 53 pertains to health hazards as they are classified under the National Primary Drinking Water Regulations established by the EPA. As these health hazards include many extremely problematic contaminants like lead, arsenic, and asbestos, the NSF 53 is one of the most vital certifications a water treatment product should have.
- NSF Standard P231: The NSF P231 assures customers that the product in question is a microbiological water purifier. A microbiological water purifier is a water filter that is extremely effective against microbiological contaminants like bacteria, viruses, and microbes.
- NSF Standard 244: The NSF 244 means that a water treatment unit can prevent accidental microbiological contamination from affecting the water quality.
- NSF Standard P401: This certification ensures that the certified water treatment device can remove or reduce at least 15 emerging compounds/incidental contaminants from water. Emerging compounds and incidental contaminants refer to potential health hazards, like microplastics, that are not yet regulated by the EPA since there’s not enough research on them.
- NSF Standard P473: Introduced in 2019, the NSF P473 relates to a certain type of emerging contaminant: PFAS. It proves that the water treatment unit efficiently removes PFAS from water.
We should note that no NSF certification is relevant to fluoride removal or reduction. However, that doesn’t mean that the certifications we just listed are any less important since NSF 53 and P473 are crucial to maintaining health standards.
In that sense, the Clearly Filtered (with 42, 53, 244, P401, and P473) and the ProOne Water Pitcher (with 42, 53, P231, P401, and P473) emerge as the best products on our list when it comes to holding important NSF certifications, as each holds five certifications. The Reshape 10-Cup Pitcher, on the other hand, is the worst because it has no NSF certifications at all.
| Water Filter Pitcher | NSF Certifications |
|---|---|
| Clearly Filtered | NSF/ANSI standards 42, 53, 244, P401, and P473 |
| Epic Pure | NSF/ANSI Standards 42, 53, 401, & P473 |
| ProOne | NSF/ANSI Standards 42, 53, P231, P401 and P473 |
| Reshape | Not Certified |
Warranty
Warranty is a testament to how much the manufacturer trusts its product. It often indicates the life expectancy of some consumer goods, especially for complicated devices like water softeners or whole-house filtration systems. Of course, water pitchers are more straightforward devices, but a reasonable warranty period is crucial to prevent unnecessary expenditures in years to come.
In that sense, Clearly Filtered and Epic Pure are the two pitchers on our list that inspire the most trust with their lifetime warranty. On the other hand, the 120-day warranty of the ProOne is quite humble for a water pitcher.
That said, we want to note that all the warranties have specific conditions regarding water temperature and other factors. Make sure you read the instruction manual of the device you purchase carefully to avoid unpleasant surprises when a malfunction occurs.
| Water Filter Pitcher | Warranty |
|---|---|
| Clearly Filtered | Lifetime |
| Epic Pure | Lifetime |
| ProOne | 120 days |
| Reshape | One year |
Price
Water filter pitchers have a cost range of $20 to $100. However, the products on our list have a narrower range, from $29.50 to $81.
The most affordable product on our list is the Reshape 10-Cup Water Pitcher, with a price tag of $29.50. The most expensive one is the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher, with a price tag of $81.
| Water Filter Pitcher | Price |
|---|---|
| Clearly Filtered | $81 |
| Epic Pure | $70 |
| ProOne | $73.95 |
| Reshape | $29.50 |
Important: The table shows prices as of the date of this writing (Jan 26th, /2023) and are subject to change.
What is Fluoride?
As we mentioned earlier, fluoride is a mineral compound naturally found on Earth. Rocks are the main source that releases it into the environment, especially in soil and water. So, many water sources, be it municipal or well water, like dams, lakes, underground water reservoirs, rivers, and the ocean, inevitably contain fluoride.
In addition to the naturally-found fluoride, municipal authorities in the United States also add it to the water supply. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), such community water fluoridation decreases tooth decay in children and young adults by 25% by increasing the resistance of tooth enamel against acids.
However, the levels of fluoride added to the public water supply range from 0.7 to 1.2 mg/L, which is well below the threshold set by the EPA: 4 mg/L. So, community water fluoridation doesn’t pose a health risk unless somebody accidentally pumps too much fluoride.
You may ask whether the already-existing and naturally-found fluoride in water can combine with the fluoridation and result in excessive levels in your drinking water. Let us assure you that it’s not possible because tap water is often treated with techniques that can remove fluoride (like reverse osmosis or distillation, which we will cover later), meaning that water is mostly fluoride-free before it’s fluoridated in a controlled manner.
On the other hand, private wells are more prone to excessive fluoride levels simply because they draw water directly from underground sources. So, if the underground water source sits on top of fluoride-rich rocks or soil, the untreated well water might have excessive fluoride levels.
Health Concerns Associated With Fluoride in Drinking Water
We have already explained that fluoride prevents tooth decay. But what about its adverse effects?
- According to the EPA, more than 4 mg/L of it can lead to skeletal fluorosis. This can lead to chronic pain and tenderness in joints. In extreme cases, it may lead to crippling.
- Additionally, although a controlled level of fluoride is good for teeth when the levels surpass 2 mg/L, it can cause tooth discoloration. Tooth discoloration isn’t a health threat, but it can also quickly become an aesthetic nuisance, especially for kids in schools where bullying based on physical appearance is a prevalent norm.
- Lastly, and maybe most importantly, research shows that consistent fluoride intake, albeit at low levels, might lead to disruption in thyroid function regardless of age
These three main points are why many Americans want to remove fluoride from their drinking water.
Main Fluoride Removal Methods in Water Treatment
The water pitchers on our list have unique filters that blend different filtration techniques. Although all of them can remove fluoride in their own ways, the brands that make them don’t disclose patented information on how they do it.
Apart from this proprietary technology, there are four main water treatment methods that are effective in removing fluoride from drinking water:
- Distillation: One of the most traditional water treatment methods, distillation is still the preference of many bottled water brands and water suppliers when it comes to the removal of fluoride and many other contaminants. During the distillation process, the water is heated until it’s all vapor, and then the vapor is condensed and cooled down so it returns to its liquid state. Since the molecules of contaminants and the ions of fluoride can’t find any solid particles to cling to in the vapor state, they are eliminated from the water.
- Reverse osmosis: Reverse osmosis (RO) is one of the most effective water treatment methods for many contaminants, and fluoride is no exception. In RO, the water pushes through a 0.0001-micron semipermeable membrane. Since this pore size is microscopic, many ions, like those of fluoride, can’t make it to the other side.
- Adsorption: As we mentioned when reviewing the Epic Pure Water Pitcher, adsorption is an effective method to remove contaminants with an anionic structure. As fluoride is an anionic mineral, adsorptive media is capable of trapping it.
- Anionic exchange: Anionic exchange employs positively charged (cationic) resin to attract and trap anions. However, this method is expensive and not suitable for household use.
Frequently Asked Questions
In this section, we’re going to answer some of the most common questions about water filter pitchers that remove fluoride.
The Clearly Filtered Water Filter Pitcher is the most effective pitcher for removing fluoride. While it’s difficult to find any device that can remove this particular mineral with a better success rate than 98%, the Clearly Filtered has an impressive reduction rate with a minimum of 99.5%.
Its success is mostly indebted to the unique structure of its filter that prolongs contact time. The twisted paths of the filter subject water to more contact time with the filter itself, thus leading to more thorough treatment.
The price range of fluoride-removing pitchers is $20 to $100, which makes their average $60. The price range of the products on our list, on the other hand, is $29.50 to $81, but with our mid-range favorites costing about $70, their average equals $64.50.
However, the initial price isn’t the only cost associated with water pitchers. The filters of these devices all have limited capacities, and you’ll need to replace them once that capacity is reached, which will add up to the long-term costs of using a pitcher.
The most budget-friendly water filter pitcher on our list is the Reshape 10-Cup Pitcher.
It’s not as effective as the high-end items on our list, nor does it have relevant NSF certifications. But according to user experience, it can eliminate the fluoride threat while remaining affordable.
Should you look hard enough, you can find manufacturers selling water filter pitchers claiming to remove fluoride for as cheap as $20. However, you can take our word that none of these products will be as effective as the Reshape 10-Cup Water Pitcher.
Conclusion
If you want to remove fluoride as effectively as possible, the Clearly Filtered Water Pitcher is the obvious choice with its 99.5% reduction rate. If you’re in the market for a more eco-friendly product, though, you can do no better than the Epic Pure Water Pitcher.
If you’re looking for a durable filter, then the ProOne Water Pitcher, with its 225-gallon capacity filter, is the answer. For those on a budget, on the other hand, the Reshape 10-Cup Water Pitcher is the ideal item, costing only $29.50.
